No, Jasmine Crockett Did Not Make Comments About a Weapon in the Karmelo Anthony Case — The Claim Is Fabricated
“Jasmine Crockett made comments about a weapon that Carmelo Anthony used to kill Austin Metcalf”
The argument in brief
Viral posts claim Rep. Jasmine Crockett made statements about a weapon used by 'Carmelo Anthony' to kill Austin Metcalf. This is false. PolitiFact, Snopes, and Lead Stories all investigated and found zero evidence — no video, no transcript, no credible reporting — that Crockett ever made such comments.
Why it spread
The story hit two emotional triggers at once: a racially charged criminal case that many people were already angry about, and a politician — Jasmine Crockett — who is a frequent target of outrage online. People who already distrusted her were primed to believe the worst, and the real details of the Metcalf case gave the fabrication just enough grounding to feel credible at a glance.
Posts circulating on social media claim that U.S. Representative Jasmine Crockett made remarks about a weapon used in the killing of Austin Metcalf, a Texas teenager stabbed to death in April 2025. The claim is fabricated. No such comments exist.
Three independent fact-checkers — PolitiFact, Snopes, and Lead Stories — all investigated and came up empty. There is no video, no transcript, no news report, and no official record of Crockett saying anything of the sort. Reuters found no corroborating wire reporting either. When multiple outlets go looking for the same evidence and all find nothing, that absence is itself meaningful.
The posts also contain a telling error: they name the suspect as 'Carmelo Anthony,' which is the name of a famous NBA player. The actual suspect in the Metcalf case is Karmelo Anthony, a teenager with no connection to the basketball star. This kind of mix-up is a common fingerprint of content that was either fabricated outright or started as a joke and got shared as fact.
To be fair to why people took this seriously: the underlying case is real and emotionally charged. Austin Metcalf was killed, Karmelo Anthony was charged, and the story drew intense national attention. It is not unreasonable to wonder what elected officials have said about it. But wondering is different from a claim being true, and no evidence supports this one.
This kind of misinformation is worth watching for because it follows a reliable playbook: take a real, high-emotion story, attach a polarizing political figure, and invent a quote. The fabricated detail feels plausible because the surrounding context is real. If you see a claim about something a politician 'said,' look for a direct source — a video clip, an official transcript, or reporting from a named outlet. If none exists, the claim almost certainly doesn't either.
Sources
- PolitiFact
PolitiFact found no evidence that Rep. Jasmine Crockett made any comments about a weapon used by Karmelo Anthony (not Carmelo Anthony the NBA player) in the killing of Austin Metcalf. The claim is fabricated.
- Snopes
Snopes investigated the viral claim and found it to be false. No credible reporting, video, or transcript supports the assertion that Crockett made such comments.
- Lead Stories
Lead Stories confirmed the claim is a hoax. The viral posts misidentify the suspect as 'Carmelo Anthony' (the NBA player) rather than the actual suspect Karmelo Anthony, and fabricate Crockett's alleged statements.
- Reuters Fact Check
No verified reporting from Reuters or other major wire services corroborates any statement by Rep. Jasmine Crockett regarding the Karmelo Anthony case or any weapon involved.
Related debunks
- UnverifiableUnverified: The Claim That Hadi Alodid Traveled Through Paris and Dublin Before Claiming Asylum in Northern Ireland
- UnverifiableNo, 'Griffith' Almost Certainly Cannot Apply for Release in 2049 — The Numbers Don't Add Up
- UnverifiableUnverifiable: The Claim That 8 Immigration Officials and 9 Visa Agents Were Arrested for Extortion