Republican Lawmaker Urges Trump to Drop Pulte DNI Appointment to Save FISA Surveillance Powers
Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act expired at midnight Friday for the first time since 2008 after Congress failed to pass an extension, following the collapse of a bipartisan renewal deal triggered by President Trump's appointment of housing regulator Bill Pulte as acting Director of National Intelligence. Trump subsequently nominated Jay Clayton, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York and former SEC chairman, as permanent DNI, but the nomination came too late to unlock Democratic votes before the deadline. The lapse raises immediate questions about national security continuity, though existing FISA court certifications approved in March 2026 are expected to allow most surveillance operations to continue through March 2027.
A bipartisan three-year extension of FISA Section 702 — which allows U.S. intelligence agencies to collect communications of foreign targets overseas without a warrant, incidentally sweeping up Americans' communications — was on track for passage until Trump announced on June 3 that he would appoint Bill Pulte, director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency and a political loyalist with no intelligence background, as acting DNI to replace the departing Tulsi Gabbard. The appointment immediately alienated Senate Democrats, who blocked a procedural vote on the extension, joined by seven Republicans with civil liberties concerns. The House then voted 218-198 against a short-term three-week extension on Thursday, with 19 Republicans joining nearly all Democrats in opposition. Trump doubled down on Pulte, directing him to begin downsizing ODNI staff, before nominating Jay Clayton — currently U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York and former Trump-era SEC chairman — as permanent DNI on Thursday afternoon; Senate Democratic leaders called Clayton 'very qualified,' but the nomination arrived after lawmakers had already left Washington for a week-long recess, with the next House vote not scheduled until June 23. Despite the statutory lapse, legal experts and the Brennan Center for Justice note that a FISA court certification issued in March 2026 authorizes existing surveillance operations through approximately March 2027, though telecommunications companies may grow reluctant to comply with new government data requests without active statutory authority, and the government would lack legal flexibility to adapt to entirely new intelligence targets.
What's missing
It remains unclear what specific legal mechanism the government would use to compel telecommunications companies to comply with new Section 702 data requests during the statutory lapse if a provider declines to cooperate, citing the absence of active statutory authority; the outcome of that potential standoff has not been tested.
How coverage differed
Right-leaning outlets such as Fox News and the Washington Times framed Democratic opposition primarily as partisan 'extortion' or hostage-taking of national security, emphasizing Trump allies' defense of Pulte and downplaying Republican dissent; center and left-leaning outlets such as AP, NPR, Wired, and the NYT gave more prominent weight to bipartisan Republican criticism of Pulte's qualifications and the statutory requirement for 'extensive' national security experience, and more fully detailed Pulte's record of using the FHFA to target Trump's political opponents as a driver of opposition.
What different sources said
- The HillCenter
Republican lawmaker says Trump can save FISA by canceling plans to put Pulte as acting DNI
- Washington ExaminerRight
House votes down FISA patch, risking first-ever lapse in key spy power
- AxiosCenter
House rejects last-ditch FISA extension ahead of Friday deadline
- NYT USLeft
House Rejects Bill to Extend Surveillance Power With FISA Section 702 Set to Expire
- ABC NewsCenter
House fails to pass short-term extension of FISA
- PBS NewsHourLeft
Trump sticks with Pulte for intel job as risk grows of lapse in spy powers
- AP NewsCenter
Trump sticks with Pulte for intel job as risk grows of lapse in spy powers
- NBC NewsLeft
FISA spying power scheduled to expire as House fails to extend it before leaving town
- NewsweekCenter
Full List of Republicans Who Voted Against FISA Renewal Despite Trump Plea
- The Straits TimesCenter
With surveillance programme at risk, Trump tries to end standoff over spy chief Bill Pulte
- PoliticoLeft
Trump asks Congress for ‘short-term’ spy law extension - Live Updates
- New York PostRight
House votes down FISA extension as lawmaker revolt grows over Bill Pulte pick as acting DNI
- NPR NewsLeft
Trump's pick for intel chief could imperil a key U.S. spy tool. Who is Bill Pulte?
- ReutersCenter
Trump nominates Jay Clayton to be next intelligence chief
- CNBCCenter
Trump picks former SEC Chairman Jay Clayton as national intelligence director
House votes against extending controversial wiretapping law set to lapse Friday
- The IndependentLeft
FISA spy powers are likely to expire after House vote collapses in bipartisan fashion
- Roll CallCenter
House vote puts surveillance authority on path to lapse
- The Guardian USLeft
Trump nominates Jay Clayton as top US intelligence official after pushback on Bill Pulte
- CBS NewsCenter
Trump taps prosecutor Jay Clayton as next director of national intelligence
- Al JazeeraLeft
Trump to pick US attorney Jay Clayton for director of national intelligence
- ForbesCenter
Trump Nominates Jay Clayton For Director Of National Intelligence After Interim Pick Pulte Derailed Congress
- Washington TimesRight
Trump taps U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton to lead national intelligence
- UPICenter
Trump now wants attorney Jay Clayton for national intelligence director
- NDTVCenter
Trump Names Prosecutor Jay Clayton New US Intelligence Chief
- BreitbartFar Right
Trump Chooses U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton as Next Intelligence Chief
- South China Morning PostCenter
Trump taps Wall Street top cop Jay Clayton as spy chief after Pulte backlash
- CNN WorldCenter
Trump says he will nominate Jay Clayton to top intelligence post amid uproar over prior, interim pick
- Fox NewsRight
Trump nominates Jay Clayton, former SEC chairman, current US Attorney, as intelligence director
- Daily WireRight
Trump Makes New Pick To Replace Tulsi Gabbard
- BBC US & CanadaCenter
Trump names new spy chief after pushback over previous pick
- The InterceptLeft
Hakeem Jeffries Finally Finds a Spine: Dem Leaders Rallied Against Extending Domestic Spy Law
- BloombergCenter
House Rejects Spy Powers Extension Amid Pulte Concerns
- The VergeLeft
A warrantless wiretap law is about to expire — but surveillance networks aren’t actually ‘going dark’
- SemaforCenter
Pulte’s new job complicates FISA renewal
- VoxLeft
Trump (still) has a spy chief problem
- National PostCenter
U.S. ambassador to Canada, Pete Hoekstra, reportedly under consideration as next national intelligence director
- The ConversationCenter
Why the director of national intelligence needs more than political loyalty to do the job
- ReasonRight
Stephen Miller and Pete Hegseth Are Wildly Misleading About Section 702 Warrantless Surveillance
- WiredLeft
Trump Risks Key Surveillance Authority Over ‘Unqualified’ Spy-Chief Pick
- The FederalistRight
If Congress Can Rush To ‘Save’ FISA, Then It Can Pass The SAVE Act To Protect America’s Elections
- EngadgetCenter
Congress lets decades-old spying law lapse amid Trump's controversial DNI nomination
- GizmodoCenter
Congress Fails to Reauthorize America's Most Powerful Surveillance Law, Which Expires at Midnight Friday
- National ReviewRight
How to Deal with the Expiration of FISA Surveillance Authority
- Ars TechnicaCenter
Controversial FISA spying law expires tonight. The spying will continue.
Congress lets part of spy law lapse. What's next for counterterrorism efforts?
- CTV NewsCenter
Trump sticks with pick for intel job, Ambassador to Canada Pete Hoekstra possible replacement: AP
- TechCrunchCenter
US surveillance law to expire for first time after lawmakers reject Trump’s controversial pick to lead spy agencies
- The Wall Street JournalCenter
Jay Clayton to the Rescue as Trump Tries to Contain Pulte Drama
- Virginia MercuryCenter
Spanberger defends wave of vetoes as frustrated Democrats push back
- Yahoo FinanceCenter
Trump’s pick to replace Tulsi Gabbard sparks a Congress stalemate as GOP leader rages vote will ‘live in infamy’
- DawnCenter
US spy powers lapse raises World Cup concerns
Trump Nominates Jay Clayton for Top Intel Role
Related
Workers Begin Removing Trump's Name from Kennedy Center Facade After Court-Ordered Deadline
Workers started stripping President Trump's name from the exterior of the Kennedy Center in Washington overnight Friday into Saturday, hours past a court-ordered deadline of 11:59 p.m. Friday. The delay was attributed to nearby thunderstorms, and the Kennedy Center's board sought a 12-hour extension, which U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper had already denied after rejecting the board's last-minute attempt to halt the order. The removal marks a significant legal rebuke of the Trump administration's effort to rename the historic performing arts venue, with a court ruling that only Congress has the authority to change the Kennedy Center's name.
Hasan Piker Campaigns for DSA-Backed NYC Candidates, Sparking Debate Over Democratic Party Direction
Twitch streamer Hasan Piker rallied in Brooklyn for two Democratic Socialist of America-endorsed congressional candidates ahead of New York's June 23 primary, declaring the country is 'closer than ever' to socialism. The appearances come amid a broader debate within the Democratic Party over whether to embrace or distance itself from Piker, whose pro-Palestinian views and provocative statements have made him a polarizing figure. The controversy highlights a growing tension between the party's centrist establishment and its increasingly left-leaning base, particularly on foreign policy.
Fire Rescue Victoria Has Missed Emergency Response Targets Every Year Since 2020, With Outer Suburbs Worst Affected
Fire Rescue Victoria (FRV) has failed to meet its target of responding to 90 per cent of structural fires within seven minutes and 42 seconds in every year since its formation in 2020, with outer suburban areas recording the worst performance. The shortfall has come into sharp focus following the death of three-year-old Jordan Dashwood in a Werribee house fire this month, where the nearest FRV truck was committed to another incident and the first responders arrived well outside the benchmark time. The findings raise serious questions about whether the 2020 fire services restructure has been adequately resourced to protect Melbourne's rapidly growing outer suburbs.