Manslaughter Charge Added to Karmelo Anthony Murder Trial Just Before Closing Arguments
A manslaughter charge was added to the indictment against Karmelo Anthony moments before closing arguments began in his trial for fatally stabbing high school athlete Austin Metcalf in April 2025. Anthony was originally charged with first-degree murder, which carries a potential life sentence, while manslaughter carries 2-20 years. The addition of the lesser charge gives jurors an alternative conviction option and could significantly reduce Anthony's potential prison time.
Karmelo Anthony's murder trial took an unexpected turn when lawyers and the judge agreed to include a manslaughter charge in the jury instructions just before closing arguments commenced. Anthony was originally indicted on a first-degree murder charge for fatally stabbing Austin Metcalf at a track event in April 2025. The prosecution argued during closing statements that Anthony acted with premeditation and intent, pointing to his flight from the scene as evidence of a "guilty mindset." The manslaughter charge requires jurors to find only that Anthony recklessly caused Metcalf's death, without requiring proof of intent to kill. The addition of this lesser charge provides jurors with a middle-ground conviction option that could result in significantly reduced sentencing—2-20 years for manslaughter versus up to life imprisonment for murder. Jury deliberations began following the completion of closing arguments.
What's missing
The circumstances that prompted the late addition of the manslaughter charge are not explained. Additionally, details about the alleged provocation mentioned in prosecution arguments and the broader context of the incident (whether self-defense claims were made, the relationship between Anthony and Metcalf, or details about the "twins" referenced in closing arguments) are incomplete.
What different sources said
- Daily WireRight
The Karmelo Anthony Trial Took An Unexpected Turn At The Last Possible Moment
Related
Mystery of New York City Manhole Visitors Remains Unsolved
Security footage from May 2024 captured multiple groups of people entering and exiting Manhattan sewers at various locations, sparking speculation about their identities and motives. The NYPD has theorized they may be scavengers seeking valuables, while some have suggested they could be urban explorers filming content. Authorities have determined the activity poses no public safety threat, though it remains illegal and dangerous.
Carriage Horse Dies Suddenly in Central Park, Reigniting Debate Over Ban
A 16-year-old carriage horse named Deniz collapsed and died in Central Park on Tuesday evening while still attached to his carriage, with the cause of death to be determined by necroscopy. The incident occurred during a heat advisory and has renewed calls for Mayor Zohran Mamdani to ban horse-drawn carriages, which have faced scrutiny over animal welfare for years. The death reignites debate over Ryder's Law, a proposed ban that would replace carriages with electric alternatives but was defeated by the City Council in 2022.
Houston Man Killed During Carjacking After Tracking Stolen Truck with GPS
Louis Erebia, 56, was shot and killed in Houston on Saturday after confronting a suspect who had stolen his son's pickup truck, which Erebia tracked using GPS. The suspect, London Hogan Sr., a repeat offender on probation, has been charged with murder, aggravated assault, and aggravated robbery. The incident highlights concerns about criminal justice outcomes when individuals with lengthy records remain in the community.